|
SELECTION CRITERIA 2014 (End of Season)
|
|
|
|
|
Total |
Performance |
Availability Points |
Loyalty Points |
Games |
|
|
|
|
|
Selection |
Points |
(Email replies) |
(Nepotists Events Attended) |
|
|
Playing Squad |
|
|
Points |
Bat |
Bowl |
Avail |
Unavail |
No Reply |
Nets |
AGM |
Golf Tour |
Oxford Tour |
50+ Games |
|
1 |
Carl Hoar |
(Eng) |
Bat-Top order |
340 |
5 |
2 |
20 |
|
|
1 |
1 |
|
1 |
1 |
20 |
|
2 |
Shahna Khan |
(Ind) |
All Rounder |
316 |
4 |
3 |
18 |
2 |
1 |
1 |
|
|
1 |
1 |
20 |
|
3 |
Steve Werren |
(Aus) |
Wkt/k |
312 |
2 |
3 |
16 |
4 |
|
1 |
1 |
1 |
1 |
1 |
20 |
|
4 |
Nilesh Naidu |
(NZ) |
Bowler |
306 |
2 |
4 |
13 |
7 |
1 |
1 |
|
1 |
1 |
1 |
20 |
|
5 |
Nilesh Thacker |
(Ind) |
All Rounder |
294 |
3 |
3 |
17 |
3 |
1 |
1 |
|
|
1 |
1 |
20 |
|
6 |
Damian Tambling |
(Zim) |
All Rounder |
264 |
5 |
5 |
12 |
8 |
1 |
|
|
|
|
|
20 |
|
7 |
Ashish Nagre |
(Ind) |
All Rounder |
264 |
3 |
3 |
12 |
8 |
1 |
1 |
|
|
1 |
|
20 |
|
8 |
Lukey Sparrow |
(Aus) |
Bowler |
264 |
2 |
4 |
12 |
8 |
1 |
1 |
|
|
1 |
|
20 |
|
9 |
Paul McCubbin |
(Aus) |
Bat-Top order |
262 |
4 |
2 |
11 |
9 |
|
1 |
|
|
1 |
|
20 |
|
10 |
Chris Ellegard |
(NZ) |
All Rounder |
259 |
5 |
3 |
6 |
13 |
2 |
|
|
|
1 |
|
20 |
|
11 |
Sanjay Thakker |
(Ind) |
Bowler |
246 |
2 |
3 |
13 |
7 |
|
1 |
|
|
1 |
|
20 |
|
12 |
Brett Schwim |
(Zim) |
All Rounder |
244 |
4 |
4 |
5 |
13 |
3 |
1 |
1 |
|
|
|
20 |
|
13 |
Viven Pillay |
(SA) |
Bat-Top order |
214 |
3 |
2 |
17 |
3 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
20 |
|
14 |
Shyam Dattani |
(Eng) |
Bat-Mid order |
197 |
2 |
2 |
13 |
6 |
2 |
|
|
|
1 |
|
20 |
|
15 |
Mick Stout |
(Eng) |
Bowler |
190 |
2 |
4 |
5 |
13 |
3 |
|
|
|
|
|
20 |
|
16 |
Aditya Khanna |
(Ind) |
Bat-Mid order |
157 |
2 |
2 |
11 |
4 |
6 |
1 |
|
|
|
|
20 |
|
17 |
Dennis McIntyre |
(Guy) |
All Rounder |
128 |
3 |
3 |
4 |
8 |
9 |
|
|
|
|
|
20 |
Legend
Bat-Top order: Players whose
batting 'Performance Points' are 3 or higher.
Bat-Mid order: Players whose batting 'Performance Points' are
below 3
Bowler:
Players whose bowling 'Performance Points' are 3 or higher.
All Rounder: Players whose batting and
bowling 'Performance Points' are both 3 or higher. (Earns 1 extra
'Performance Point' each week)
Performance Points highlighted in red
on the table above are
the skippers evaluation of batting and bowling rankings for players who
have not yet qualified (ie) 5 completed 'career' innings with the bat or
scored 200 runs and been to the crease 5 times (including not outs); or bowled 30
'career' overs and bowled in 5 matches. The evaluation is the lowest ranking the player is
likely to achieve, and hopefully will go up as 'form' kicks in.
_________________________________________________________________________________________
SHORT VERSION
Points are awarded weekly as follows:
Total Selection Points = Availability Points + Performance Points
+ Loyalty Points
Availability Points
8 pts Reply to weekly email as 'Available'
(Before 12pm Wed)
8 pts Reply to weekly email as 'Available if short' (Before
12pm Wed)
6 pts Reply to weekly email as 'Unavailable'
(Before 12pm Wed)
0 pts No reply to weekly email
Performance Points
These points are awarded based on your career averages with Nepotists
CC, not just the current season (unless it is your first season). You are only awarded the full
performance points for either your batting or
bowling (whichever is highest), plus 1 extra performance point if both your
batting and bowling are each 3 pts or higher (All Rounder).
Batting
5 pts Batting average is 40 runs
or more
4 pts Batting average is between 30 and 40 runs
3 pts Batting average is between 20 and 30 runs
2 pts Batting average
is between 10 and 20 runs
1 pt Batting average is less than 10 runs
Bowling
Bowling points are based equally on your bowling ave (runs per wicket) and economy rate (runs per over), then divided by 2 to give a final ranking out
of 5 (Rounded up).
Average
5 pts Bowling average is less than 15 runs per wicket
4 pts Bowling average is between 15 and 20 runs per wicket
3 pts Bowling average is between 20 and 25 runs per wicket
2 pts Bowling average is between 25 and 30 runs per wicket
1 pt Bowling average is more than 30 runs per
wicket
Economy
5 pts Economy rate is less than 4.5 runs per over
4 pts Economy rate is between 4.5 and 5.0 runs per
over
3 pts Economy rate is between 5.0 and 5.5 runs per
over
2 pts Economy rate is between 5.5 and 6.0 runs per
over
1 pt Economy rate is more than 6 runs per
over
Wicketkeeper
3 pts
Loyalty Points
1 pt If you attend '2 out of the 3' nets at Lords pre season
(either netting or socialising)
1 pt If you attend the Nepotists CC 'Annual General Meeting'
(AGM)
1 pt If you attend the Devon Golf Tour in July for at least 1 day, even if
you don't play
1 pt If you attend the Oxford Cricket Tour in Aug for a least 1 day, even if
you don't play
1 pt If you have played 50 or more career games for Nepotists CC
Lifeline
Each player is granted one 'Lifeline', which means your first 'No Reply'
to the weekly email will be disregarded and you will be granted points as if you
replied 'Unavailable', even if you are subsequently selected to play. After
you've used up your 'Lifeline', you will receive no points for any further 'No
Replies'. By not replying to the weekly email you lose on average around 13-16
points.
_________________________________________________________________________________________
DETAILED VERSION
Selection Criteria
Selection each week is based on several factors, the main one being how often
you reply to the 'Availability' emails each week, and to a lesser extent on your
cricketing ability and loyalty to the club. This selection process will only be
enacted on occasions throughout the season when more than 11 regular players are
available for selection. It is mainly designed to reward people for making the
skipper's life a lot easier. So basically the team will pick itself each week,
(ie) the players will decide their own fate. If you are not going to be
available for a period of up to 3 weeks, simply let the skipper know, who will note it
down on your behalf. This will save you replying each week while you're
temporarily unavailable.
Preference for selection will be given to those players who are part of the
'Playing Squad',
(ie) those players who wish to participate in games throughout the season on a
regular or semi regular basis, and also reply to the weekly 'Availability'
emails. (See current 'Playing Squad' above).
Only the 'Playing Squad' members need reply each week, but anyone else can
declare their availability for selection, but will only be selected if the team
is short of regular players. There are exceptions however - see 'Nepotism Rule'
below. Also, if you fail to reply to the availability email in 4 consecutive
weeks, you will automatically be removed from the 'Playing Squad', but can
rejoin the squad (alas with a lot less selection points), simply by letting the
skipper know and buying him a couple of beers after your first game back!
A table is produced at midday every Wed with a running count of each players
points, and selection will be based on how high you are on the list and the
requirements of a 'balanced team' of batsmen and bowlers, (ie) there must be at
least 5 'recognised' bowlers selected if available. But the higher up
the list, the more likely you will be selected. Remember, if you don't reply you
don't get any points!
This selection criteria is presently a work in motion, and will be continually
changed and adapted till the fairest system is found. Therefore these are not
hard and fast rules, and other factors such as opposition strength etc, will be
looked at before any decision is made.
Total Selection Points = Availability Points + Performance Points +
Loyalty Points
Availability Points
Players are rewarded for replying to the weekly 'Availability' email by midday
Wed each week, and bonus points for being available
to play. If you
reply (or are contacted) after the deadline, even if declaring your availability, you gain no
points. If you declare 'Available' or 'Available if Short' and are not selected to play, you will
still get the full points.
Points are awarded as follows:
8 pts Reply to weekly email as 'Available'
(Before 12pm Wed)
8 pts Reply to weekly email as 'Available if short' (Before
12pm Wed)
6 pts Reply to weekly email as 'Unavailable'
(Before 12pm Wed)
0 pts No reply to weekly email
Performance Points
These are based on your cricketing ability. Just a quick note here. Nepotists Cricket
Club never has (or ever will be) purely about cricketing ability, and rightly
so, as the ethos of the club has always been about having a run around on top
class cricket fields with mates on a Sunday afternoon, without any 'League'
mentality, or the result of the match being everything, but of course
competitive; followed by a few beers and a bit of banter in the bar after the
game. But this cricketing ability section is a necessary addition designed to
balance out the team, as opposed to selecting a team based purely on email
replies. Otherwise for example, the team could end up with11 batsmen one week or
11 bowlers another week. This will also help any temporary or future skippers to
be able to fall straight into the job if so required with minimal effort, and
will
hopefully take away from the Nepotists skipper the long term frustrating part of
continually chasing up players for availability.
You are only awarded the full performance points for either your batting or
bowling (whichever is highest), plus 1 extra performance point if both your
batting and bowling are each 3 pts or higher (All Rounder).
Batting and bowling rankings are based on you're 'career' record with the club,
not just the current season. If it is
your first year or you haven't played enough games to qualify, below is what you
need to do to qualify:
Batting Qualification: Been dismissed 5 times, or have scored 200 runs and been to the crease 5 times
(including not outs).
Bowling Qualification: Bowled 30 overs and bowled in at least 5 matches.
For those who haven't qualified, a subjective evaluation will be made at 'nets'
by the skipper, or over the first few games you play. The skipper will select
the lowest Levels of batting and bowling which he thinks you may achieve once
you have qualified, and hopefully this will go up as you play more games and the
season wears on.
These rankings can fluctuate throughout the season for newer players until 'form' has been established, but is unlikely to
change too much for longer term players during the current season.
Points are awarded as follows:
Batting
5 pts Batting average is 40 runs
or more
4 pts Batting average is between 30 and 40 runs
3 pts Batting average is between 20 and 30 runs
2 pt Batting average
is between 10 and 20 runs
1 pt Batting average is less than 10 runs
Bowling
Bowling points are based equally on your bowling average (runs per wicket)
and economy rate (runs per over), then divided by 2 to give a final ranking out
of 5 (Rounded up).
Average
5 pts Bowling average is less than 15 runs per wicket
4 pts Bowling average is between 15 and 20 runs per wicket
3 pts Bowling average is between 20 and 25 runs per wicket
2 pts Bowling average is between 25 and 30 runs per wicket
1 pt Bowling average is more than 30 runs per
wicket
Economy
5 pts Economy rate is less than 4.5 runs per over
4 pts Economy rate is between 4.5 and 5.0 runs per
over
3 pts Economy rate is between 5.0 and 5.5 runs per
over
2 pts Economy rate is between 5.5 and 6.0 runs per
over
1 pt Economy rate is more than 6 runs per
over
Your final Performance Points are based on the following. You are only awarded
the full points for either your batting or bowling (whichever is highest),
plus 1 extra point if both your batting and bowling are each 3 pts or
higher. (All Rounder)
Example 1: If you are a Level 4 batsman and a Level 3 bowler, your
combined
batting & bowling points is 5 (ie) 4 points for batting and 1 extra point
for being an Allrounder.
Example 2: If you are a Level 4 batsman and a Level 2 bowler, your
combined
batting & bowling points is 4 (ie) 4 points for batting and 0 points for bowling.
Example 2: If you are a Level 4 batsman and a Level 5 bowler, your combined
batting & bowling points is 6 (ie) 5 points for bowling and 1 extra point for
being an Allrounder.
Wicket Keeper
The wicket keeper is a specialist position, and will be regarded the same as a Level 3 bowler for the sake of
completeness.
3 pts Wicketkeeper
Loyalty Points
You are awarded 1 extra point each week for every
Nepotists CC event (below) you have attended in the previous 12 months before the current game, or
have played 50+ career games for the Nepotists. (eg) If you've attended '2 out
of the 3' nets at Lords + 'attended the AGM' + been on the 'Oxford Tour', you
get 3 extra points per week for every game you reply to.
Points are awarded as follows:
1 pt If you attend '2 out of the 3' nets at Lords pre season
(either netting or socialising)
1 pt If you attend the Nepotists CC 'Annual General Meeting'
(AGM)
1 pt If you attend the Devon Golf Tour in July for at least 1 day, even if
you don't play
1 pt If you attend the Oxford Cricket Tour in Aug for a least 1 day, even if
you don't play
1 pt If you have played 50 or more career games for Nepotists CC
Lifeline
Each player is granted one 'Lifeline', which means your first 'No Reply'
to the weekly email will be disregarded and you will be granted points as if you
replied 'Unavailable', even if you are subsequently selected to play. After
you've used up your 'Lifeline', you will receive no points for any further 'No
Replies'. By not replying to the weekly email you lose on average around 13-16
points.
More Examples
Example 1
If you are a Level 3 batsman and a Level 1 bowler, and you reply to
the weekly email as 'Available' before midday Wed, you will receive 11
points for that week.
(ie) 3 (batting pts) + 0 (bowling pts) + 8 (email reply pts) + 0 (loyalty pts) = 11pts
Example 2
If you are a Level 3 batsman and a Level 4 bowler, and you reply to the
weekly email as 'Unavailable' before 12pm Wed, and you have also been on the
Oxford Cricket Tour, and been to the AGM, you will
receive 13 points for that week.
(ie) 1 (allrounder pt) + 4 (bowling pts) + 6 (email reply pts) + 2 (loyalty pts) = 13 pts
Example 3
You are a Level 2 batsman and a Level 1 bowler, and you reply to the weekly
email as 'Unavailable if short' before 12pm Wed, you will
receive 10 points for that week.
(ie) 2 (batting pts) + 0 (bowling pts) + 8 (email reply pts) +0 (loyalty pts) =
10 pts
Example 4
You are any Level batsman or bowler, and you don't reply to the weekly
email, you receive no points for that week.
Example 5
You are any Level batsman or bowler, and you reply to the weekly email
after midday Wed (or are contacted for your availability), and you are still
selected to play, you receive no points for that week.
Nepotism Rule
Exceptions will be made for:
1) Players who have been with the club for more than 15 years, and only play very infrequently, sometimes years apart.
2) Players who have been part of the 'Playing Squad' in recent years, and are
visiting the UK for a short period.
Under most circumstances a place in the team would be made available to these
players.
|